![]() | |
![]() ![]() |
"My Statement to the House of Commons Committee" BORN IN CANADA BUT NOT CANADIAN?
Lost Canadian Children are natural-born Canadians, without having to earn or qualify to be worthy of citizenship, their God-given birthright gives each inalienable rights to nationality that can't be taken away by civil government, except by forfeiture. Parliamentarians gave little of the future and the unfairness they'd create for these children, wherein nationality and citizenship were stripped from them virtually forever!
Each story is unique, in mine, Canada claimed I lost nationality and citizenship "automatically" as a child when my mother brought me to the States. My relatives, MP's, Senators and House of Commons Members, even strangers, could never understand why I wasn't a Canadian citizen, even more so a dual citizen! I was a mere child, not having attained the age of majority to renounce or acquire a country's citizenship, nor given due process or choice of allegiance as accorded by the Canadian Citizenship Act! The 1977 Citizenship Act came along in an attempt to correct the law by making it impossible to loose nationality and citizenship. However, it was a failure and only continued to be unjustifiably unfair to those of us who lost it automatically prior to 1977 who had to still deal with the inequities, injustices and consequences of archaic laws! If laws supposedly evolved to correct past injustices for others, including children born abroad, Japanese immigrants, First Nations, even Senators and House of Commons Members born outside Canada, why hadn't it evolved for those of us born in Canada? It was apparent, Parliament would have to pass a bill that would .... "REDRESS the years of unfairness and heartache of all born in Canada whom as children unjustifiably and automatically lost Nationality and Citizenship. It should be made right once and for all, anything but "Automatic Resumption" for Lost Canadian Children and their Descendants will only continue to divide and torment those families for years to come!" |
family history, my ggg-grandfather Duncan MacLaren journeyed to P.E.I. from Scotland onboard the "FALMOUTH" in 1770. The picture with my brother Ross, was taken the day I went to the States. Although I was only six, I remember it as if it was yesterday, especially how I felt leaving my brother, aunts and uncles. I remember saying good bye to all my cats and our horse Flicka, but most of all my buddy, Rover. For certain, the fondest memories on the Island was of a simpler time where kindness, respect, love of family and country was formed in those early years, never to be forgotten! I was made a naturalized U.S. citizen on January 26, 1955 as a child ten years of age, when I was told to raise my hand and pledge an OATH to be a citizen of the United States! That innocent act as a minor, could never change my BIRTHRIGHT, my heritage or feeling in my heart that Canada was my true home, the States only my temporary home.
Early trips to the States weren't easy; my mother sought work as a domestic; we moved from one job to another, one room at a time, many nights we went to bed hungry. One employer, refusing to have worker's children in their home, meant my being placed in a Massachusetts foster home. I remember the rows of beds and treatment sometimes dealt to the children. The UNITED STATES was "THE LAND OF PROMISE". What is so obviously different then, Congress had the common sense not to bankrupt it's citizens and future generations by handing out WELFARE, FOOD STAMPS and MEDICAL to IMMIGRANTS! Life moved on, I attended American schools and at age ten became a citizen but even in my young heart I was always looking forward to going downhome, even if it was for only a few weeks in the summer. I grew up without knowing details behind my immigration or of my Canadian family I left behind. I married my beautiful wife Gloria in 1968, we honeymooned on PEI and brought up three children on Cape Cod, that was close enough for us to make frequent jaunts to the Island. I remember saying one day we would move back and rebuild the old homestead where I was born. That's gone now, only bits of the frame of the old spool bed I was born on remained. |
"WHEN ARE YOU COMING HOME BOBBY" That's what my relatives always asked, oh God, I wish they were still around, they'd be so happy and proud of me regaining my citizenship! Unfortunately their words turned to sadness and desperation as the years rolled by, especially after coming to realize what both countries had done. I presumed being born in Canada made me an automatic dual citizen, when crossing the border, I always took pride showing my birth certificate to prove I was Canadian! In fact, in 1987 I made plans to move my family to the PEI with an idea to start a small business. I applied to the CIC but was devastated to be denied citizenship resumption. I re-applied in 1995 and 2001 and in February, 2002. Finally, CIC closed my application without any possible consideration or referral to a citizenship judge!
In early 2000, in Los Angeles, an unsympathetic young Asian Immigration officer, herself a dual citizen, had the audacity to tell my daughter and I to forget FOREVER about ever trying to regain our Canadian citizenship! It was definitely time to journey North to settle this once and for all or forever hold my peace! I'd have to wait another eight months for written correspondence from CIC but I was able to spread my story around and contact the office of M.P. Dr. James Lunney on Vancouver Island. Though Mr. Lunney never took up my cause personally, his associates, John McLaughlin and Gayle Goodman tried exhaustively to help me deal with the Sydney CIC. Perhaps, in a small way, we were able to stir the pot and perhaps perk up a few ears in Parliament.
|
"The News"- Parksville, B.C. www.pqbnews.com ![]() On a trip home to Prince Edward Island on family business, I spoke with Lawrence A. Macaulay, P.C., M.P. A true gentleman, he took time to listen and his disbelief of the decisions made by CIC was heartening, however we both realized there was still a long road ahead. You see, I'd always respectfully disagreed with the CIC. Their decisions solely based on Subsection 20 (1) of the Canadian Citizenship Act of 1952 reads; "when the responsible parent of a minor child ceases to be a Canadian citizen, the minor child would cease if he acquired the nationality of his responsible parent simultaneously; the inclusion of the minor child in the mother's U.S. naturalization resulted in automatic loss of the minor child's Canadian citizenship effective January 26, 1955." Certainly an adult is held accountable if they renounce citizenship but our society and laws say a child is never held accountable for acts of a parent, the link between child and parent is a particularly unique and intimate nature wherein the child has no choice who their parents are or where, when and if they choose to divorce or immigrate, therefore Canada and CIC is holding me to a doctrine of "discrimination by association". |